Heads up! Due to Amazon’s policy changes, TheReviewIndex.com is permanently down. Our team is pouring that energy into something new - ACME.BOT - a friendly AI SEO blog writer. We’d love for you to check it out!
Last Updated: June 3, 2019 (Refresh Now)
Stacy Adams Men s Dickinson Cap Toe Lace up Oxford
Last Updated: June 3, 2019 (Refresh Now)
8.7
SCORE
/10
Total Reviews
989
Old Reviews
168
Unverified
49
Spam Test
PASS
Review Analysis - 772 recent, verified reviews
Detailed Mode
Comfort
242shoe, fit, leather, dress, look
+85%
-15%
" ... Sharp looking and comfortable! ... "
" ... We repeatedly buy this shoe for my husband to wear to work, they hold up well, look great when polished and run true to size!! ... "
" ... Very comfortable shoes. ... "
" ... The shoes look and feel amazing! ... "
" ... Good looking and very comfortable for strolls ... "
" ... Very sharp, first day wearing them and I have been complimented on them several times. ... "
" ... The quality, style and width and oh yeah comfort is perfect. ... Ps- he is wearing them for work too! ... "
" ... They look good, although I bought a gel insole to make them feel better. ... "
Design
146shoes, compliments, shoe, fit, stylish
+99%
-1%
" ... It looks OK ... "
" ... They are good quality and look great. ... "
" ... It is a combination leather and man made upper but it still looks great in black. ... however for the look and style of it with a suit it looks as good or better than anything around $150 for the cost of $65. ... Seriously, very comfortable shoe and very stylish for a very polished look! ... "
" ... Great looking dress shoes with a high dollar look and feel. ... "
" ... Very nice dress shoes. ... "
" ... They look nice though. ... "
" ... I'm in love & with the compliments ... "
" ... These shoes beautifully complimented my suit and looked amazing. ... "
Fit
141shoes, shoe, fit as expected, look, wide
+91%
-9%
" ... My wife really likes them and I like the way they fit and look. ... "
" ... They fit a little tight in the toe and overall as well. ... "
" ... Was as described and fit was exact. ... "
" ... I ordered the same in this shoe and they fit fine but I can see how some might think they run big. ... "
" ... These fit the bill perfectly. ... "
" ... Too early fits perfectly for my broad feet. ... "
" ... Perfect fit and very comfortable ... "
" ... fit as expected, beautiful color and style! ... "
Build Quality
77shoe, shoes, soles, heel, sole
+61%
-39%
" ... Good quality, but a bit tight/narrow. ... "
" ... The leather is flexible enough to be comfortable, but the soles are not very soft under your feet. ... "
" ... I received many compliments when I wore them last weekend. ... "
" ... These shoes are very nice, feels like I paid allot of money for them. ... "
" ... These shoes looked really good for 6 solid months of wear 3-4 days per week. ... The leather wears well ... even with noticible wear and tear, the leather aged nicely. ... "
" ... They look extremely stylish with the combination of black leather and brown soles. ... In fact, they don't have any chemical smell or strong leather smell. ... The finish is glossy but not like patent leather which is good. ... "
" ... Perfect Leather shoe. ... "
" ... The shoe looks great but I can see the middle bending already ... "
Price
70shoes, nice, shoe, value, dress
+97%
-3%
" ... Other than that I’d say these are a very nice option for the price. ... "
" ... Great product worth while investment ... "
" ... Extremely nice shoes, especially at this price point. ... "
" ... Solid dress shoe for the price. ... "
" ... This is the best price I could find. ... For the price, this is an excellent par of shoes. ... "
" ... Good shoes for the price . ... "
" ... Very nice shoes at a fair price ... "
" ... Overall a very nice dress shoe for the price. ... If you're looking for a somewhat high quality oxford at a reasonable price, look no further. ... "
Color
30shoes, shoe, colors, love the color, fit
+100%
" ... Bought the cognac color. ... "
" ... same color as the picture, good quality, fit the real size ... "
" ... Now I bought this color. ... "
" ... Style and color is what it does describe on online. ... "
" ... Great shoes, colors and all. ... "
" ... The color is great in person and looks even better in the natural light. ... "
" ... If you are looking for a shoe with that deep honey brown color this is definitely the one to select! ... "
" ... The color of shoe and The Price . ... "
Size
27true to size, shoes, larger, smaller, shoe
+74%
-26%
" ... True to size. ... "
" ... Very consistent shoe quality and size. ... "
" ... Great shoes, however too large, had to order a smaller size. ... "
" ... Just a heads up, you may potentially need to order 1/2 to 1 size below your usual size depending on how you like them to fit. ... "
" ... I have no issues at all in terms of quality and size. ... "
" ... Amazing shoes for under $60, just buy a half-to-full size smaller and you won't be sorry. ... "
" ... He is a size 9. ... "
" ... We thought that if we ordered a larger size it would help. ... "
Marketplace
26color, shoes, amazon, thank, shown
+88%
-12%
" ... Thank you very much to deliver my order and be the one that I was looking for. ... "
" ... Fast shipping and as advertised ... "
" ... The shoes I got looked slightly different than the picture but Great non the less! ... "
" ... same color as the picture, good quality, fit the real size ... "
" ... They must have been written prematurely. ... "
" ... Not quite as red as the picture would suggest, but a really great product for the price. ... "
" ... Thank you to the person at Amazon who knows what I want. ... "
" ... Would order again ... "
Band
25leather, shoes, shoe, dress shoes, compliments
+68%
-32%
" ... I have received compliments when worn with black jeans but they go well with slacks and dockers as well. ... "
" ... I wore these shoes right out of the box and got several compliments on them. ... "
" ... More comfortable than most dress shoes. ... "
" ... The leather is very soft and comfortable to wear. ... "
" ... Very nice dress shoes. ... "
" ... I received a lot of compliments when i wear them. ... "
" ... They also have a nice shine that completes the look when wearing a suit. ... "
" ... The leather wears well ... even with noticible wear and tear, the leather aged nicely. ... "
For Kids
23husband, loves these shoes, son, shoes, look
+96%
-4%
" ... Just got these shoes for my dad (75 years old) and he loves them. ... "
" ... He loves them! ... "
" ... Husband loves them! ... "
" ... my husband loves these shoes. ... "
" ... My husband loves these shoes! ... "
" ... Bought for my son. ... He loves them. ... "
" ... My husband loves these shoes. ... "
" ... Husband loves them and they look great on him. ... "
Product Reliability
17last, weeks, shoes, sole, month
+65%
-35%
" ... Worked out great! ... "
" ... They'll get you through an interview and your first few months! ... "
" ... But again, for the price a pair a year is cool with me. ... "
" ... Will see how durable it will be the coming months. ... "
" ... Hope it last longer as well. ... "
" ... Not sure of how long they'll last, but look good for now. ... "
" ... Will buy again when these need replaced. ... "
" ... I'll let you know more in a couple of months ... "
Product As Described
13color, shoes, shown, shoe, pictures
+85%
-15%
" ... Nice shoes, different color as shown in picture, but its also nice. ... "
" ... Received as advertised. ... "
" ... Better than the picture. ... "
" ... The shoes I got looked slightly different than the picture but Great non the less! ... "
" ... They looked just like the picture ... "
" ... same color as the picture, good quality, fit the real size ... "
" ... Color is exactly what is shown in the picture. ... "
" ... Look awesome, less red-toned than the picture. ... "
Returns
12shoes, need, process, ended
+17%
-83%
" ... I have to return them. ... "
" ... Just received these shoes, but have to return them. ... Will try again once the return process has concluded. ... "
" ... I will be asking for my money back! ... "
" ... I had to return them and will order a wider version. ... "
" ... Of course it starts happening as soon as my return period has ended. ... "
" ... Had to return it because a medium width was just not wide enough. ... "
" ... Instead of a13w, I need to exchange them for a 14w or a15w. ... "
" ... So now I’ll need to return two pairs of shoes. ... "
As Gift
7bought, husband
+100%
" ... Ok, so my husband loves these & has bought them as gifts for 2 people. ... "
" ... He liked them so much he got a pair as a gift for his cousin. ... "
" ... Bought these as a gift for my husband! ... "
" ... Bought these as a gift for my husband. ... "
" ... Bought as a gift for my hubby. ... "
" ... Bought as a gift. ... "
" ... Was a gift. ... "
Picture Quality
6quality, color, price, like, good
+100%
" ... They looked just like the picture ... "
" ... Better than the picture. ... "
" ... Sharp and comfortable, not as much contrast as in the picture but still stylish ... "
" ... Not quite as red as the picture would suggest, but a really great product for the price. ... "
" ... same color as the picture, good quality, fit the real size ... "
For Running
5wear, normal, big, size, shoes
+40%
-60%
" ... When walking bunches up under toes. ... "
" ... These definitely run larger than normal. ... "
" ... Because of this, I can only wear these if I put bandaids on my heels and don't walk very far in them. ... "
Delivery
5shoes, delivery, stacy, received, packaged
+80%
-20%
" ... Shipped fast and arrived fast! ... "
" ... Received as advertised. ... "
" ... love the shoes and great delivery time. ... "
" ... Delivery was on time and in good condition. ... "
Storage
4shoes, space, shoe, wide, half
+100%
" ... Luckily it’s very suitable when I just received and tried- a little more space make me more comfortable, the next day today I started to change this new shoes and dropped that 4years old one. ... "
" ... it feels spacious vey nice shoe. ... "
" ... These shoes are a good half to full size bigger than what a typical 9.5 would be. ... "
Review Spam Test PASS
In order to keep our review summaries as accurate as possible, we aggressively detect fake reviews. We use various signals to detect unnatural patterns and will gradually expose them here.
Specifications
No specs available.