Last Updated: January 9, 2020 (Refresh Now)
Sam Edelman Women s Tinsley Rain Boot
Last Updated: January 9, 2020 (Refresh Now)
7.7
SCORE
/10
Total Reviews
999
Old Reviews
308
Unverified
33
Spam Test
PASS
Review Analysis - 658 recent, verified reviews
Detailed Mode
Comfort
247ankle, shoes, boots, shoe, ankles
+62%
-38%
" ... A bit snug but they are easy to wear. ... "
" ... I've only worn these boots a few days now but so far so good! ... "
" ... I’ve worn them several times now since it’s been rainy around here lately. ... "
" ... Very comfortable shoes, and clean easily ... "
" ... These boots are my new favorite shoe to wear. ... They are super comfy and I have been getting so many compliments. ... "
" ... I LOVE them and knew I wanted a newer pair to have available as my older pair are getting a bit worn out. ... They fit as expected: I typically wear a 9.5 and ordered a 10 since they don't run in half sizes. ... "
" ... Passed them along to my sister and purchased a 10, which fits comfortably. ... "
" ... I was able to wear the size 10 comfortably all day while wearing a pair of thick socks. ... "
Fit
124boots, shoe, shoes, socks, size
+77%
-23%
" ... Once on the fit was fine. ... "
" ... Stylish and fit well. ... "
" ... I liked the color and the length fit was perfect. ... "
" ... I decided to try it again with the insoles and - miracle of miracles - the boots had stretched just enough so that they now fit perfectly. ... "
" ... A few years ago I purchased a pair of Sam Edelman fashion boots in a wide width, and was hoping the fit would be just a good. ... They arrived in just 2 days and fit perfect. ... "
" ... But other than that the width and stuff was a nice snug fit. ... "
" ... So cute, but the insole on the right one came undone and moves while walking. ... "
" ... The eight fits perfectly. ... "
Build Quality
110thick socks, shoe, shoes, elastic, socks
+39%
-61%
" ... The bottoms are not slipped resistant either. ... "
" ... I think it's the plastic but it was unbearable. ... "
" ... And the elastic part made it worse. ... "
" ... Too narrow and the material is hard ... "
" ... They fit pretty well, but the sole inserts have fallen apart, the outer matte paint has started to scuff pretty badly, and the tread is already getting worn out. ... "
" ... Had to put inserts into them because they are flat inside. ... Inside falling apart after four months of regular wear. ... "
" ... Flakes of the shoe were falling off both inside and out. ... "
" ... Bad plastic smell! ... "
Design
108stylish, boots, lots of compliments, compliments, shoes
+96%
-4%
" ... The aesthetic is very chic tho, so if you’re willing to suffer for fashion go for it, but order at least a size up! ... "
" ... Look good though. ... "
" ... They are durable and look great. ... "
" ... I’ve never recieved so many compliments on shoes, let alone rainboots! ... "
" ... Today is the first time I've worn them and I feel super cute. ... "
" ... Matte finish is great and allows these shoes to be more versatile. ... Stylish and fit well. ... "
" ... Love these, get compliments all the time that they look more expensive. ... "
" ... These are really cute—cute enough to wear for work—but that’s ALL they have going for them. ... Looks cute, but not comfortable, and not worth it. ... "
Overall performance
51love these boots, boot, love, wanted, look
+92%
-8%
" ... Love these boots! ... "
" ... LOVE THESE BOOTS! ... "
" ... Love the boot. ... "
" ... Great looking boots! ... "
" ... I was so excited about these boots! ... "
" ... Love the boots!! ... "
" ... This is my favorite boot right now. ... "
" ... does the job ... "
Size
50true to size, 7, tight, ordered a size, 9
+78%
-22%
" ... Length good for me. ... "
" ... You should order one size up. ... "
" ... I don't know if they just didn't get wider as the size got bigger? ... "
" ... They arrived on time, felt great size and width wise, and seems like decent quality. ... "
" ... They fit true to size. ... "
" ... I definitely feel as though they are true to size. ... "
" ... They fit true to size. ... "
" ... Liked quality, but ordered my size and they were too small. ... "
Color
43love the color, colors, green, different colors, color is perfect
+98%
-2%
" ... These are durable and the color is perfect. ... "
" ... Very stiff but beautiful color! ... "
" ... I do like their selection of colors. ... "
" ... I got the Hunter Green color, which is a great neutral. ... "
" ... Will order again in other colors. ... "
" ... I like the color and ankle length. ... "
" ... I love the colour ... "
" ... The color is perfect and I will wear them with everything. ... "
Water Resistance
32rain, water, shoes, puddles, boots
+78%
-22%
" ... So comfortable and water resistant ... "
" ... These pictures are taken after I cleaned them off with soap and water ... "
" ... If you need rain proof these are so cute ... "
" ... I expect them to as they are listed as waterproof. ... "
" ... Love these rain booties!! ... "
" ... first, comfortable, then waterproof of course, and finally : they look great! ... "
" ... Looks like a cute boot but waterproof, amazing for the NW weather up here. ... "
" ... Protect my feet from water completely. ... "
Returns
26returning, wish i could, returned, refund, support
+12%
-88%
" ... Had to return both orders. ... "
" ... So now I have to deal with a return and reorder item. ... They don’t do exchanges better off going through Zappos. ... "
" ... I would return if I could ... "
" ... I wish I could return these!!! ... "
" ... Had to return. ... "
" ... Unfortunately had to return. ... "
" ... I will be returning these! ... "
" ... I returned these. ... "
Band
21wearing, elastic, ankle, shoe, rub
+38%
-62%
" ... The lining inside the shoe came off after wearing it only twice. ... "
" ... I received lots of compliments while wearing these but I'm giving ONE star because after wearing them once the inside sole came loose and made it very uncomfortable to walk in. ... "
" ... Inside falling apart after four months of regular wear. ... "
" ... These shoes came unglued after two wears! ... "
" ... I could not have worn thick socks in them. ... "
" ... After only wearing them twice, the insole lining is already peeling. ... "
" ... *The elastic sides wear-off easily. ... "
" ... One of the shoes elastic part was ripped and it looked like it was only glued and not sewed in. ... "
Price
20worth, money, penny, felt, considering
+80%
-20%
" ... If they were wider they'd be the perfect shoe for the price point! ... "
" ... The price is unbeatable ... "
" ... Well worth every penny. ... "
" ... I felt like the price I paid for these was perfect. ... "
" ... Very cute and great price! ... "
" ... Good looking, bought it with a great price. ... "
" ... Worth the price ... "
" ... These boots are amazing for the price. ... "
Drying
19feet, stylish, kept my feet, keep my feet, boots
+95%
-5%
" ... Loved the boots kept my feet warm and dry ... "
" ... My feet stayed dry though despite the heavy rains which is what I wanted! ... Overall - great boot for the price and perfect for someone looking to stay dry without compromising style. ... "
" ... These did exactly what I wanted, which was keep my feet warm and dry on rainy days, but still look professional enough for work. ... "
" ... My feet stay dry and warm! ... "
" ... These boots look great while keeping your feet dry! ... "
" ... My feet stayed dry, comfortable, stylish and warm (it was about 35 degrees out) the whole time. ... "
" ... These booties have been a great purchase because they're light weight and keep my feet dry. ... "
" ... Quality is good as well and works perfectly to block water and keep your feet dry. ... "
For Travel
16weather, rainy, boots, wore, vacation
+88%
-13%
" ... They are great for rainy weather and I walked several miles daily in them while on vacation and they were still comfortable! ... "
" ... An easy go to boot for a quick trip outside, yard work, or tryna look cute :) ... "
" ... They’ve been though a lot of hiking and mud but they’re perfect and a great price! ... "
" ... I bought these for my sister to wear while studying abroad and she loves them. ... "
" ... I had an 8-day European vacation planned and the weather was looking pretty bleak as I was packing. ... "
" ... I was looking for rain boots to take on our spring break trip to the Safe in Austin Rescue Ranch when I saw these Sam Edelman boots. ... "
" ... and also the color, my coworkers ordered too, while traveling on winter snow season, and they love it. ... "
" ... The weather during the trip was just as promised and these boots delivered! ... Anyway, even though the trip is over, I’ll continue to wear these boots for a while! ... "
Product Reliability
14boots, weeks, days, pair, ago
+71%
-29%
" ... But I notice it even after a few months. ... "
" ... I have owned these same boots in black matte for 1.5+ years. ... "
" ... It works well on rainy days. ... "
" ... I bought this boot couple months ago to prepare the rain this year. ... "
" ... I absolutely love these boots, I wasn’t expecting much since they were cheap but I’ve had them for 6 months now and they’re still holding up perfectly! ... "
" ... This is my second pair of these boots in 4 years! ... "
" ... Great for rainy days ... "
" ... I hope they last. ... "
For Running
13run, rain, narrow, wore, run a bit
+69%
-31%
" ... I highly recommend these rain boots if you are looking to buy a pair. ... "
" ... My daughter loved these boots. ... "
" ... These are ideal for running around and not sacrificing style. ... "
" ... I would say run a little small, if you are choosing to size up or down. ... "
" ... I wore these boots for our most recent week of rain and they were great! ... "
" ... I wore them for extended walks between my house and my bus stop without them. ... "
" ... I like that I can still look professional while wearing these boots. ... "
" ... They fit as expected: I typically wear a 9.5 and ordered a 10 since they don't run in half sizes. ... "
Ease of Use
12easy, walk, take, easy to get, slip
+92%
-8%
" ... Very easy to pull on and off, their best feature. ... "
" ... With the loop at the back they're easy to get on ... "
" ... I got the matte color black, very sleek, but they do scuff fairly easy. ... "
" ... however, they are easy to put on and off, so that's a good thing for me. ... "
" ... These are also comfier than your average rainboot and much easier to put on and take off. ... "
" ... Easy to slip on and off. ... "
" ... easy to put on. ... "
" ... Easy to put on and take off ... "
Marketplace
11like the picture, way, picture, photo, look
+100%
" ... They are very nice looking, just like in the photo posted by the seller. ... "
" ... better than the photo ... "
" ... Please, check the pics. ... "
" ... I love the way these look in the pictures, but they felt cheaper in-person. ... "
" ... I always tell them Amazon! ... "
" ... I love the color look like the picture ... "
" ... I ordered them because I saw them on my favorite blogger's site extrapetite.com. ... "
" ... Stylish and the product looks just like the picture. ... "
Cleaning
10wet, toe, smell, shoes, floor
+80%
-20%
" ... Shoes have very clean lines, which is why I purchased. ... "
" ... Going to try to clean them somehow to take away the smell ... "
" ... Wanted something to wear that would be easy to clean. ... "
" ... They look a bit roughened up, with typical scrapes on the toe box, but the aesthetic of the boot is still very clean. ... "
" ... Very comfortable shoes, and clean easily ... "
" ... The style is clean and I love the color. ... "
Product As Described
7like the picture, way, picture, photo, look
+100%
" ... I love the color look like the picture ... "
" ... better than the photo ... "
" ... I love the way these look in the pictures, but they felt cheaper in-person. ... "
" ... Stylish and the product looks just like the picture. ... "
" ... I bought the Sangria and I love the color- it matches the picture. ... "
" ... Please, check the pics. ... "
Capacity
6room, narrow, wiggle, wide, size
+50%
-50%
" ... Really tight on the top of my feet ... "
" ... I struggled getting my feet in and I have relatively small feet. ... "
" ... The bottoms are removable and are made for very narrow feet. ... "
Storage
6room, 8, thick socks, shoes, narrow
+83%
-17%
" ... For the most part they fit great but, could have used just a tiny bit more room. ... "
" ... When I tried it on, it did fit like a "spacious" narrow foot person that could be filled with thick socks with that extra "spacious" space. ... Please note that I say spacious sarcastically. ... "
" ... There will be room for thick socks. ... "
" ... Purchased size 7 and it fits beautifully. ... "
" ... I bought my true size which is 8 and have room for a medium weight sock. ... "
For Kids
5loves, college, bought
+100%
" ... Son hermosas y de muy buena calidad, justo lo que buscaba❤ ... "
" ... I bought this for my daughter. ... "
" ... I ordered these for my daughter in Washington and she loves them. ... "
" ... Exactly what my college student wanted. ... "
" ... I'm writing for my 19 year old daughter. ... "
Delivery
4today, opened, received, delivered
+100%
" ... Arrived sooner than expected. ... "
" ... They were delivered today. ... "
" ... And they look just as advertised upon arrival. ... "
Review Spam Test PASS
In order to keep our review summaries as accurate as possible, we aggressively detect fake reviews. We use various signals to detect unnatural patterns and will gradually expose them here.
PASS
Unverified Review Streak
PASS
High Velocity Reviewers
PASS
Inactive Reviewers
PASS
Reviewer History Overlap
Specifications
No specs available.