Last Updated: January 6, 2019 (Refresh Now)
Old Stone Oven Rectangular Pizza Stone
Last Updated: January 6, 2019 (Refresh Now)
8.0
SCORE
/10
Total Reviews
1000
Old Reviews
696
Unverified
54
Spam Test
PASS
Review Analysis - 250 recent, verified reviews
Detailed Mode
Food Items
122stone, oven, crust, bread, pizzas
+84%
-16%
" ... It's not only great for baking breads and pizzas, it also helps your oven to maintain its temperature even if you need to open it frequently. ... "
" ... What can I say I love Pizza and Bread, ... "
" ... Just started making my own pizza at home from scratch. ... The pizza stone take about 30 minutes to heat up in my electric non-convection oven at 500F. ... There will be stains on the pizza stone, but it doe not affect the heating or taste of the pizza. ... "
" ... Takes a while to heat up properly but it throws heat into my pizza and bread really well. ... "
" ... This stone bakes great pizza from frozen or scratch. ... "
" ... Great pizza stone. ... "
" ... We use this stone regularly for our home made pizzas, excellent quality, and should last a long time if you take care of it. ... Follow the instructions for proper preheating, and the pizza will come out great. ... "
" ... Bought two of these as gifts for family and they love making pizza now. ... "
Baking
40bread, baking, stone, bake, oven
+95%
-5%
" ... What can I say I love Pizza and Bread, ... "
" ... Got this with Bread Illustrated. ... Both should be considered as gifts to the bread maker of your family and friends. ... "
" ... I use this to bake bread on and I love it. ... "
" ... I am looking forward to using it for baking and even certainly a must have for Pizza night. ... "
" ... Great stone it's bigger than a round pizza stone so you can do a larger pizza or two loaves of bread and it's thick be sure to let it get hot in over for 15 min at least 30 is better. ... This stone stayed warm 12 hours after baking bread it's a real good buy. ... "
" ... I ordered this because a friend recommended it - I will never cook pizza without it again. ... "
" ... Makes a fab baking surface for pizza and similar breads. ... "
" ... Love the smell of Pizza in the house, or Syrian bread. ... After cooking, you can scrape, brush, or lightly sandpaper it. ... "
Programs
22grill, stone, rack, bake, pizza
+95%
-5%
" ... Have used in the oven and BBQ for months now. ... "
" ... I use this often, and it stays in my oven. ... "
" ... Also fits perfectly on my infrared grill. ... "
" ... perfect pizza evertime, on the grill or oven. ... "
" ... Keep it in the oven. ... "
" ... Plan on using this on outdoor grill but have only used it in the oven so far with great success. ... "
" ... This recipe sets preheated oven at 500F. ... "
" ... First oven stone i have had and it has been great. ... "
Cleaning
20stone, stains, rinse, pizza, crust
+60%
-40%
" ... It cleans up easily with just a rinse of water. ... "
" ... The pizzas are cooked in about 7-9 minutes, the bottom of the crust is crisp without being burnt and clean up was super easy. ... "
" ... I’ve had no odor issues or clean up issues, if it breaks, I’m ordering another ASAP. ... "
" ... Easy to use,cleans up, the crust is like bread - crunchy yet soft. ... "
" ... It is big enough for a sloppy first timer and cleaned up nicely. ... "
" ... It work fine if I could figure out how to clean the stains on it ... "
" ... Be sure to run the stone through at least one high-heat or oven-cleaning cycle before cooking on it. ... "
" ... Over time it’s building up a nice seasoning from oil and grease to make it Non-stick and easier to clean. ... "
Heating
14heat, stone, pizza stone, heats, food
+79%
-21%
" ... Heats up evenly. ... "
" ... Everything above it heats well without burning. ... "
" ... Very cool pizza stone, fits in standard oven great, I leave it in there all the time, heats up great and helps cook other food more evenly too. ... "
" ... Also really great for keeping things warm without burning them up in the oven! ... "
" ... Oh and I leave mine right in the oven, it does take a little longer to heat up but it's worth it. ... "
" ... Excellent heat distribution! ... "
" ... Let it come up to temp in your oven as your oven comes up to temp. ... "
" ... The mass holds heat evenly and perfectly transfers it to the food, just be sure to preheat you oven to the desired temperature and let the stone come up to temperature and you are ready. ... "
Product Reliability
13defective, using, stone, months, returned
+62%
-38%
" ... I anticipate many years of enjoyment from this product ... "
" ... I've been using this product for a few months now and I'm quite satisfied with it. ... "
" ... No complaints over the years and it continues to perform year after year and despite rough handling. ... "
" ... I've been using it for a few months now, and I don't know how I ever lived without it. ... "
" ... After using this for many months now, I am very happy with it. ... "
" ... Have been using this for a few months now. ... "
" ... I used my stone for the first time today and it worked beautifully. ... "
Size
13heavy, handle, stone, shape, picture
+85%
-15%
" ... Larger size allows me to make larger baked good or several smaller ones at the same time. ... "
" ... The size is great. ... "
" ... Nice size, good quality . ... "
" ... Heavy duty - works great at 500*! ... "
" ... Very high quality material and ample size! ... "
" ... Also, considering the size, it's actually pretty light and easy to handle. ... "
" ... Great size, shape. ... "
" ... Very nice, but it is very heavy! ... "
Build Quality
13stone, warped, rough, pizza, cracked
+62%
-38%
" ... Definitely a quality product that should last many years of heavy use. ... "
" ... Heavy duty - works great at 500*! ... "
" ... No complaints over the years and it continues to perform year after year and despite rough handling. ... "
" ... Well packed with heavy duty foam liner. ... Seems to be a good quality and heavy. ... "
" ... The item is fairly heavy and well-made. ... "
" ... nice and heavy duty . ... "
" ... Nice, solid, heavy stone. ... "
" ... It is great for the price and is made in the U.S.A. of U.S.A sourced materials. ... "
Returns
10returned, time, returning, replacement, one
-100%
" ... I returned it. ... "
" ... It’s such a pain to return something though I think this was someone else’s return . ... "
" ... So, I reported the problem and requested a replacement. ... "
" ... The second one is going back for a refund, I've wasted more that $30 of my time dealing with this product and I still have to re-pack and drop off the second one. ... "
" ... Returning the stone. ... "
" ... Being my third time using the stone, it is too late to return it . ... "
" ... I am super annoyed that there is no easy way to return or get a remedy from the manufacturer! ... "
" ... Returned the first one thinking it was defective. ... However, replacement was worse. ... "
Price
9stones, investment, fair
+100%
" ... Previously I have received wonderful products that work perfectly and just cost a little less. ... "
" ... Great product for the price. ... "
" ... I thought the price was reasonable and the performance is great. ... "
" ... I have no comparison but also no regrets and some stones go for over $100.00 for the price it could very well be the best buy ... "
" ... It works as intended, the price is fair. ... "
" ... Overall, I'm satisfied with it and a reasonable price. ... "
" ... Best newlywed investment ever!! ... "
Ease of Use
7use, oven, heavy, handle, friendly
+71%
-29%
" ... Easy to use. ... "
" ... Easy to use in oven. ... "
Marketplace
7stone, raised, size, pizza, picture
+57%
-43%
" ... Flawless exchange with Amazon. ... "
" ... Supposedly the # 1 (Amazon Recommended) pizza stone on Amazon . ... Amazon if your listening, I would love a response . ... "
" ... Just as described. ... "
Delivery
6arrived, well, well packaged, pizza, perfect condition
+83%
-17%
" ... Arrived in perfect condition and very well packaged. ... "
" ... So far so good, arrived in one piece and has been used for pizza and roasting veggies. ... "
" ... Great stone, came well packaged. ... "
" ... It was packaged very well and was in perfect condition. ... "
Defective Delivery
6item, first, defective, well, returned
+17%
-83%
" ... The package had obviously been opened and taped back together. ... "
" ... Nobody wants to go through the process of returning a defective item that never should have been sent in the first place. ... "
" ... Returned the first one thinking it was defective. ... "
" ... The only thing is, I may have received a faulty one, because mine wobbles when placed on a flat surface. ... "
" ... it is a horrible product or mine is defective. ... "
Storage
6rack, well, space, size, perfectly
+100%
" ... Very high quality material and ample size! ... "
" ... It fits perfectly in our standard oven, and there were no odors at all when we first used it. ... "
" ... I do "store" It right in my oven all of the time, a definite advantage, so it does not require any extra space in my rather small house. ... "
" ... I have zero problem with it except for one item concerning the directions for storage. ... "
" ... The tiles are about the same thickness (about 1/2 inch). ... "
" ... Handles 500 degrees very nicely. ... "
Fit
6fits, well, stone, perfectly, rack
+83%
-17%
" ... It fits perfectly in our standard oven, and there were no odors at all when we first used it. ... "
" ... It fits in my oven, which was a concern in the beginning looking for a stone. ... "
" ... Also fits perfectly on my infrared grill. ... "
" ... Fits, works, and most importantly, cooks the underside as one would hope. ... "
" ... It is big enough to fit two good sized loafs on. ... "
Ease of Cleaning
4easy, stains, easy to clean
+100%
" ... It is big enough for a sloppy first timer and cleaned up nicely. ... "
" ... Cleans up well. ... "
Setup
3followed, first, stone, directions
-100%
" ... Make sure to follow the instructions and "season" the stone by putting it on broil first to set the stone and burn off any impurities. ... "
" ... We have followed the instructions. ... "
" ... I wrote it off as the curing process . ... "
Capacity
3making, kitchen, home, bbq, bake
+67%
-33%
" ... The tiles can be used for BBQ. ... "
" ... Such a wonderful addition to any kitchen! ... "
As Gift
3christmas, got
+67%
-33%
" ... It was a gift for our daughter for Christmas. ... "
" ... It is a gift for Christmas so I have not used it. ... "
Product As Described
3raised, size, picture, described, bottom
+33%
-67%
" ... The pictures don't show the bottom of the stone, there is a raised square section in the middle and two raised feet on each edge. ... "
" ... The stone I received has a raised border and logo, NOT what the pic depicts! ... "
Cooling
3+67%
-33%
" ... After the stone cools down, rinse with water (no soap) and scrub. ... "
Review Spam Test PASS
In order to keep our review summaries as accurate as possible, we aggressively detect fake reviews. We use various signals to detect unnatural patterns and will gradually expose them here.
PASS
Unverified Review Streak
PASS
High Velocity Reviewers
PASS
Inactive Reviewers
PASS
Reviewer History Overlap
Specifications
No specs available.