Last Updated: August 25, 2021 (Refresh Now)
Mantello Royal Glass Top Cigar Humidor Desktop Humidifier Storage Box for 25 50 Cigars With Hygrometer Divider Handcrafted Rosewood Finish Cedar Wood Case for Moisture Control Gift for Men
Last Updated: August 25, 2021 (Refresh Now)
8.4
SCORE
/10
Total Reviews
1000
Old Reviews
523
Unverified
53
Spam Test
PASS
Review Analysis - 424 recent, verified reviews
Detailed Mode
Body
129cigars, glass, beautiful, wood, hygrometer
+84%
-16%
" ... Still seasoning the humidor, but construction is solid and results of seasoning look to be excellent. ... "
" ... I like the glass so I can see the hygrometer reading, since I bought a separate one. ... Also, it's a good solid piece that seems substantial given the weight. ... "
" ... This one really fits the bill. ... "
" ... Love the ability to see thru the glass and it looks as decor good in my ofc. ... "
" ... I bought it to preserve 25 cigars I brought back from Cuba, and it fits everything with loads of room to spare. ... I planned on storing this in my closet somewhere until I got it and realized how aesthetically appealing it is in person. ... "
" ... Hygrometer is crap but it looks very nice on the bourbon cabinet. ... "
" ... I bought this for myself to hold my small collection. ... "
" ... Holds a good seal. ... "
Usage
85instructions, humidor, easy, christmas, loves
+93%
-7%
" ... Easy to setup. ... "
" ... I purchased this for my husband as a starter and he loves it. ... It is well crafted and is a beautiful piece in our dining room. ... "
" ... He absolutely loves it!! ... "
" ... I liked it so much I bought one to give as a gift. ... "
" ... Bought this as a Christmas gift for my boyfriend. ... "
" ... Follow the instructions and all will be good. ... "
" ... It is an amazing gift. ... "
" ... Its definitely not the fanciest humidor out there but its nice, simple and effective. ... "
Price
66money, humidor, waste, value, reasonable price
+91%
-9%
" ... The cost was good compared to others as well. ... "
" ... Good quality and you dont have to spend alot of money ... "
" ... Great humidor for the price. ... "
" ... Good value for the money. ... "
" ... Highly reccommended for anyone who wants a good product for the price ... "
" ... Once it’s been seasoned it hold humidity better than you would expect for the price tag. ... Would recommend for someone that’s just getting into this sort of thing cheap price tag but very very good quality. ... "
" ... The quality and craftsmanship are first rate - excellent. ... "
" ... I love the look and price point of this item. ... "
Body / Design
64wood, humidor, finish, classy, craftsmanship
+94%
-6%
" ... The humidor looks great has a nice smooth finish on it and the felt on the bottom makes it easy to move and does not scratch any of my surfaces the only thing about the box is that the hygrometer on it takes a while to calibrate and is inaccurate i also purchased a digital hydrometer which fixes that problem but over all the product is great. ... "
" ... It looks very nice. ... "
" ... Humidor is well built & looks great. ... "
" ... Craftsmanship and overall appearance are above expectation. ... "
" ... The quality is great, very aesthetically pleasing and the wood on inside was easy to season. ... "
" ... We love the wood finishes! ... "
" ... It does if there is no manufacturing flaw (mine is free of flaws and it is beautiful little box). ... "
" ... The construction of the box is great and finish look really good. ... "
Body / Build Quality
52wood, humidor, hygrometer, seal, glass top
+73%
-27%
" ... It's well built and the wood looks great. ... "
" ... People are always looking through the glass and commenting about it/them. ... "
" ... Construction and quality seems good. ... "
" ... I can see my Cigars through the glass and they smell good when you open the case. ... "
" ... Still seasoning the humidor, but construction is solid and results of seasoning look to be excellent. ... "
" ... Pretty good build quality. ... "
" ... The craftsmanship and wood quality is very good and smells great. ... The lid seals well and I have no issue holding 68-70%. ... I also have the humidor by Case Eligance with the digital hygrometer, and the digital hygrometer I used to verify this humidor, also matches the Case Eligance hygrometer, so should be accurate. ... I like the look of this humidor a little more than the Case Eligance humidor, due to the more reddish wood color of this one. ... "
" ... It was easy to cure the wood and good quality craftsmanship. ... "
Usage / As Gift
42christmas, husband, loves, cigars, humidor
+100%
" ... It's a great gift idea! ... "
" ... Perfect birthday gift! ... "
" ... It's for a Christmas gift. ... "
" ... I got this for my boyfriend for Valentine’s day and let’s just say I won gift giving lol. ... "
" ... It is an amazing gift. ... "
" ... Very awesome gift to buy for someone. ... "
" ... I bought this as a gift for a friend and he loves it. ... "
" ... As a gift. ... "
Marketplace
33arrived, packaged, humidor, return, described
+85%
-15%
" ... All around great box ... "
" ... The packaging was good and the humidor completely safe through normal shipping. ... "
" ... Humidor came packaged well. ... "
" ... You also can put your cigar set inside the box. ... "
" ... Pretty good box overall. ... "
" ... Arrived as advertised ... "
" ... Works as advertised. ... "
" ... Box seems nicely made. ... If it wasn’t a hassle for me to return it I would. ... "
Body / Fit
27seal, cigars, humidor, hygrometer, divider
+52%
-48%
" ... You can fit Churchill's in there which is a plus for me. ... "
" ... Can hold up to 100 cigars if packed tight. ... "
" ... The seal seems to be a very good fit. ... "
" ... Holds everything I need and was seasoned in almost no time at all. ... "
" ... Holds a good seal. ... "
" ... This one really fits the bill. ... "
" ... I bought him 2 different cigar samplers, a total of about 36 cigars, and they all fit easily with room to spare. ... "
" ... It holds about 30 cigars for me anyway. ... "
Usage / Ease
24instructions, simple, set, seasoning, humidor
+88%
-13%
" ... Great product with easy setup and great instructions ... "
" ... The instructions were clear and precise. ... "
" ... Just the right size for a beginner ... "
" ... Easy to setup. ... "
" ... This humidor is crafted very nicely and the seasoning instructions were easy to follow. ... "
" ... Easy to prep and set up. ... "
" ... Its definitely not the fanciest humidor out there but its nice, simple and effective. ... "
" ... Follow directions and set up is fairly simple. ... "
Body / Storage
22cigars, humidor, 50 cigars, room, crafted
+100%
" ... Product arrived quickly, beautifully crafted, holds 20-50 cigars. ... "
" ... Not something you are going to build a collection or use for long-term storage, but its a nice piece to have on a desk or coffee table. ... "
" ... I bought this for myself to hold my small collection. ... "
" ... It holds about 30 cigars for me anyway. ... "
" ... Holds everything I need and was seasoned in almost no time at all. ... "
" ... Hygrometer is crap but it looks very nice on the bourbon cabinet. ... "
" ... This humidor has enough room to stack a bunch of cigars but some airflow is preferred for cigars so it will keep a half dozen or so spaced nicely. ... "
" ... The lid seals well and I have no issue holding 68-70%. ... "
Usage / Setup
21easy, set, seasoning, simple, followed
+95%
-5%
" ... It came with a very easy to followed seasoning guide which took 3 days in my case and it's been held steady at 72% for about a week before dropping steadily. ... "
" ... Easy to setup. ... "
" ... This humidor is crafted very nicely and the seasoning instructions were easy to follow. ... "
" ... It comes with easy seasoning instructions. ... "
" ... Make sure to follow the instructions that ship with it, regarding the initial conditions, and otherwise it’s great. ... "
" ... Easy to use and set up so long as you follow directions. ... "
" ... Follow directions and set up is fairly simple. ... "
" ... Setup is super simple (bottle water is fine) and the cigars are now lasting over 2 weeks compared to the previously few days without having this. ... "
Marketplace / Delivery
19packaged, arrived, humidor, delivered, condition
+100%
" ... Timely delivery and product looks great. ... "
" ... Product came as described. ... "
" ... Box seems nicely made. ... "
" ... It arrived quickly, was packaged nicely, and well made. ... "
" ... I was surprised how great the product was when I opened the box. ... "
" ... Pretty good box overall. ... "
" ... The box it was delivered in was well packed as was the mfgr. ... "
" ... Delivery was quick & the curing was quick & easy. ... "
Reliability
18months, seasoned, weeks, season, humidity
+50%
-50%
" ... So not worth it and about to return for being defective. ... "
" ... I've properly seasoned for over 2 weeks and also have a Boveda pack inside and not matter what I do it will not keep a steady number. ... "
" ... I have had it for multiple months and have tried on 4-5 occasions to season it and it will not hold. ... "
" ... UPDATE: it’s been less than a month since my last review and alas, I’m disappointed again. ... Ok, it’s been a few months and I can’t change the score/rating. ... "
" ... It will be difficult to maintain if I have to season the humidor one every few days. ... "
" ... Our molded within a month - really disappointing. ... "
" ... This is my first humidor so it might be human error but i really don't think so, I seasoned it twice over a period of 48 hours and it's just not holding moisture in. ... "
" ... I’ve had this a couple of months now and at first just thought I was a humidor master but now I realized the dial always reads 70% humidity. ... "
Body / Size
11small, humidor, perfect size, good, really
+100%
" ... Although I haven't owned this humidor long, its impressed me as a quality small humidor. ... "
" ... This one really fits the bill. ... "
" ... I bought this for myself to hold my small collection. ... "
" ... It's the perfect size for my space. ... "
" ... I wanted a size that I would grow into. ... "
" ... It is just the right size. ... "
" ... The perfect size and well made ... "
" ... Very good construction for the price, I would recommend seasoning with the 84% boveda packs you will need 2 for the size of this humidor. ... "
Accuracy
10hygrometer, digital one, digital, humidor, inaccurate
+90%
-10%
" ... After calibrating the Hygrometer, I surprisingly found it to be accurate. ... "
" ... It is very accurate and I monitor it everyday to check on what I need to keep it between the lines to keep my cigars fresh. ... "
" ... The analog hygrometer is surprisingly accurate when checked against the digital one that I keep inside. ... "
" ... The hydrometer seems to be accurate. ... "
" ... Well-made and accurate humidor at an amazing price. ... "
" ... The humidor is nicely crafted, looks great, and the reader appears accurate. ... "
" ... The analog one is not accurate without preparing it whereas a digital one is accurate right out of it's packaging. ... "
" ... I did buy a $4 digital hygrometer, so I can have an accurate humidity reading. ... "
Usage / Capacity
8humidor, plenty, house, living, humidity
+88%
-13%
" ... The craftsmanship is so good that I have the humidor on one of my living room end table for anyone to see. ... "
" ... I currently have 20 Ghurka's in there and there's room for more! ... "
" ... I put 25 cigars in with plenty of room left for more ... "
" ... I would definitely recommend to a friend/family member for just starting out. ... "
" ... This is a great little humidor for the house. ... "
" ... Well made and can house many of my cigars. ... "
" ... It is well crafted and is a beautiful piece in our dining room. ... "
Marketplace / Marketplace
8works, product, described, came, advertised
+100%
" ... Also noteworthy is how great the customer service was with this seller. ... "
" ... I did receive mine from Amazon approved in “used-like new”condition. ... "
" ... One of my best purchases from Amazon👍🏿👍🏿 ... "
" ... Product came as described. ... "
" ... Product works as advertised. ... "
" ... Works as advertised. ... "
Usage / For Kids
7loves, purchased, gave, christmas, bought
+86%
-14%
" ... I gave this to my son for Christmas and he loves it ... "
" ... Purchased for my son for Christmas and he was thrilled . ... "
" ... He absolutely loves it!! ... "
" ... Bought this for my son. ... "
" ... I purchased this for my husband as a starter and he loves it. ... "
" ... I bought this for my son. ... "
Performance
7humidor, performance, looks, good, cigars
+86%
-14%
" ... Beautiful Humidor, does the job (I’ve only had it about a week though). ... "
" ... The humidor is doing the job of keeping my cigars fresh. ... "
" ... And does the job it is supposed to do well. ... "
" ... Overall, it’s a great case and does the job right when seasoned. ... "
" ... Basically performance is king with a humidor so I’ll tell you a bit about non-performance related thoughts and much more about seasoning and maintaining this humidor over the last 31 days. ... "
" ... Looks good on the desk and does its job. ... "
Cleaning
5sponge, season, humidor, wiping, cedar
+40%
-60%
" ... So what I do is leave a cup of distilled water in it just to try to keep it up to 40% but most of the time it’s at 35%. ... "
" ... Followed all instructions but dries out cigars instantly and has also wasted all humidor packs placed inside. ... "
" ... But then a gel leaked and while cleaning up found out it was particleboard with a cedar front. ... "
Marketplace / Product As Described
4product, described, came, advertised, picture
+100%
" ... Product came as described. ... "
" ... Product works as advertised. ... "
" ... Works as advertised. ... "
Marketplace / Defective Delivery
4packaged, hygrometer, broken
+50%
-50%
" ... My biggest disappointment is the hygrometer showed up crooked and broken. ... "
" ... Item arrived damaged. ... "
Cooling
4room, temperature, really, humidor, cigars
+75%
-25%
" ... No problems keeping consistent humidity. ... "
" ... It’s also worth noting that the ambient room temperature was between 66 and 69 degrees the entire time with near constant A/C so there were likely no major changes in room humidity that would skew the results in the humidor. ... "
" ... Maintains humidity very good. ... "
Color
4wood, well, picture, nice, love
+100%
" ... Pretty color, glass top, looks nice. ... "
" ... I like the look of this humidor a little more than the Case Eligance humidor, due to the more reddish wood color of this one. ... "
" ... Color is excellent, well put together. ... "
" ... I really love the wood and color. ... "
Marketplace / Returns
3would, replacement, one, buying, another
+33%
-67%
" ... So not worth it and about to return for being defective. ... "
" ... If you had the misfortune of missing your return deadline date like I did, here’s some advice: ... "
Marketplace / Packing
3packed, humidor, packaged
+100%
" ... Humidor came packaged well. ... "
" ... VERY well packed no damage at all! ... "
" ... The packaging was good and the humidor completely safe through normal shipping. ... "
Dry
3cigars, humidor, dried, months, drying
+33%
-67%
" ... Cigars dried out. ... "
" ... It's dry in my basement now, around 38 percent so it has been impossible to hold in the humidor. ... "
Body / Comfort
3however, 60, seal, humidor, hinges
-100%
" ... etc, it will go to 72 percent for about three days, and then fall back again to low 60's. ... "
" ... However this is an exception I have 3 gel sticks in it to keep it at 70% however it won’t stay at anything above 60 even after doing the water treatment it still just drops below 60 into the 50s. ... "
Review Spam Test PASS
In order to keep our review summaries as accurate as possible, we aggressively detect fake reviews. We use various signals to detect unnatural patterns and will gradually expose them here.
PASS
Review Count Per Reviewer
PASS
Unverified Review Streak
PASS
High Velocity Reviewers
PASS
Inactive Reviewers
PASS
Reviewer History Overlap
Specifications
No specs available.