Last Updated: May 23, 2019 (Refresh Now)
Magic Mesh New and Improved Hands Free Magnetic Screen Fits Doors Up to Up to 83 x 39 Black
Last Updated: May 23, 2019 (Refresh Now)
6.2
SCORE
/10
Total Reviews
525
Old Reviews
204
Unverified
89
Spam Test
WARN
83 meters
SIZE
Review Analysis - 232 recent, verified reviews
Detailed Mode
Build Quality
63velcro, apart, mesh, fell, falling
+24%
-76%
" ... Does not stick to painted metal frame ... "
" ... Mesh tore across top. ... Find the one with the overlapping closure instead. ... "
" ... This is cheaply made. ... The first day all the magnets came apart. ... "
" ... Very cheaply made unfortunately. ... "
" ... Small portions of the screen had small tears and the outside lining is so weak it tears to pieces like a thin thread. ... "
" ... CHEAPLY MADE CRAP! ... "
" ... We've had it up 4 days and the screen is so thin it has already torn away from the magnetic strip. ... Not sturdy at all. ... "
" ... Very cheaply made. ... "
Fit
53velcro, apart, falling, tacks, magnets fell
+28%
-72%
" ... falls apart in 4 to 5 months ... "
" ... This product is great at first but within days the magnets all start falling off! ... "
" ... This one is not heavy duty and the magnets are on the outside of the seem so they fall off. ... "
" ... The only problem I have with this product is that the magnets fall out of the plastic case they are in, preventing the screen to stay closed. ... "
" ... The clamp that holds the magnet easily falls apart i have to put a tape on each of them for them to be secured. ... "
" ... The only drawback is if it is fairly windy, and the dog goes out, the magnets don't always close automatically back up because of the breeze. ... "
" ... Its not really worth the $17, the tape dont stick as advertised ... "
" ... One magnet was missing and one fell out during install. ... "
Door
36open, screen, bugs, doors, velcro
+81%
-19%
" ... Had always loved the magic mesh and purchased several before but we installed a new screen sliding door (didn't have one before) and was not able to install it. ... "
" ... Bought this for a relative that had no way to install a screen door. ... Their door and when it's really windy it sound like a machine gun because the magnets adhere to the door. ... "
" ... This will fit a standard, indoor sized door frame. ... "
" ... Works perfect for my back door that doesnt have a screen and is almost impossible to have one installed. ... "
" ... On very windy days we just colse the door. ... "
" ... I've had it installed in my garage entrance door for about 3 weeks now and I love it. ... "
" ... Ours is hung in a single door frame and has held up so far with a 4 and 5 year old running through it. ... "
" ... I love my screen door. ... "
Product Reliability
27year, ripped, lasted, month, mesh
+44%
-56%
" ... falls apart in 4 to 5 months ... "
" ... This product seemed great when I put it up, but not even a month after purchase it had holes and had to be taken down. ... "
" ... I replaced them but now the mesh is failing to close. ... "
" ... The seems started coming loose within 3-4 weeks. ... "
" ... Ripped within a month. ... "
" ... Ripped after a week ... "
" ... this year two weeks and I have to throw it away Do not buy ... "
" ... We've purchased a new one of these every year, but had to throw this one out! ... "
Comfort
23velcro, falling, sticky, hands, fell
+13%
-87%
" ... The sticky velcro doesn't hold it up well and it is a pain to be sure you get everything exactly straight or you will have a gap. ... "
" ... This one is not heavy duty and the magnets are on the outside of the seem so they fall off. ... "
" ... Several magnets fell off as I was putting it up. ... "
" ... It tore the moment we put it up. ... "
" ... It's falling apart. ... "
" ... Now, it’s little pieces of Velcro that you have to attach to the fabric. ... "
" ... The magnets continued to fall apart, the Velcro did not stay. ... "
" ... the magnets are just literally falling off. ... "
Setup
21install, installation, easy, way, easy to put
+90%
-10%
" ... Each person seems to have the best way to modifying the installation. ... "
" ... Great for my pet to go in and out of the the house and easy installation. ... "
" ... easy to install - keeps the bugs out ... "
" ... Easy install and even extra Velcro and tacks included. ... "
" ... Easy to put up, after I read the directions (it's a guy thing). ... "
" ... It was fairly easy to install and reasonably priced. ... "
" ... Install is easy and quick. ... "
" ... Easy to install but that's it. ... "
Ease of Use
21easy to put, easy, install, works, put
+95%
-5%
" ... This item was easy to put up . ... "
" ... It was fairly easy to install and reasonably priced. ... "
" ... Easy to step up and keep bugs out ... "
" ... My husband said it was really easy to install, too. ... "
" ... Install is easy and quick. ... "
" ... Easy to install. ... "
" ... Easy to put up, after I read the directions (it's a guy thing). ... "
" ... easy to install - keeps the bugs out ... "
Display Clarity
18door, ripped, magnets, fabric, works as advertised
+78%
-22%
" ... Great screen to keep the bugs out and let the dogs in/out of the house ... "
" ... Much sturdier than last hanging screen that I had. ... "
" ... Bought this for a relative that had no way to install a screen door. ... "
" ... The screen works as advertised. ... "
" ... I love my screen door. ... "
" ... Love this screen. ... Works perfect for my back door that doesnt have a screen and is almost impossible to have one installed. ... "
" ... Works poorly and fairly, easy to put up , the magnets that close the screen work poorly with very few alignment , I put it up right but there are gaps in the fabric that allow in bugs. ... "
" ... Previously the magnets were sewn into the fabric now they are attached in little plastic boxes that pop open every time the screen is moved and then the magnets fall out of the little plastic boxes it’s a total piece of crap. ... "
Band
17fell, falling, velcro, one, fall apart
+6%
-94%
" ... The magnets fell off in one day of use i would give a no star review if i could! ... "
" ... Several magnets fell off as I was putting it up. ... "
" ... The Velcro is not strong enough to hold. ... Kept falling off. ... "
" ... The magnets continued to fall apart, the Velcro did not stay. ... "
" ... the magnets are just literally falling off. ... "
" ... It's falling apart. ... "
" ... Has only been a week or so and it's starting to fall apart :( ... "
" ... Find the one with the overlapping closure instead. ... "
Marketplace
15vendor, thank, product, original, another
+60%
-40%
" ... THANK goodness for this product! ... "
" ... Absolutely perfect, and does exactly what the company describes. ... "
" ... Works as advertised! ... "
" ... Thank you for such a good product! ... "
" ... The screen works as advertised. ... "
" ... Thank goodness it's PRIME! ... "
" ... It's an original product. ... "
Screen Protection
11magnets, fabric, sewn, ripped, poorly
+73%
-27%
" ... Previously the magnets were sewn into the fabric now they are attached in little plastic boxes that pop open every time the screen is moved and then the magnets fall out of the little plastic boxes it’s a total piece of crap. ... "
" ... Have purchased this screen for several years now. ... "
" ... Works poorly and fairly, easy to put up , the magnets that close the screen work poorly with very few alignment , I put it up right but there are gaps in the fabric that allow in bugs. ... "
" ... Much sturdier than last hanging screen that I had. ... "
" ... I have tried a couple of these magnetic screens and have come back to this one. ... "
" ... Love this screen. ... "
" ... Have had this screen mesh up for 3 months now. ... "
Price
10waste, would, worth, really, price
+40%
-60%
" ... Don’t waste your money. ... "
" ... I guess you get what you pay for. ... "
" ... A waste of $13.00, then again, it was only $13.00. ... "
" ... WASTE OF TIME/MONEY. ... "
" ... Not worth buying. ... "
" ... Total waste of money. ... "
Capacity
9flies, works, traffic, screen, porch
+100%
" ... Great for my pet to go in and out of the the house and easy installation. ... "
" ... A great screen door for my terrace,very happy with it.👍 ... "
" ... It's been absolutely perfect for our tiny apartment! ... "
" ... Where I live it doesn't really get hot enough for AC most days, but having the afternoon breeze clear the air in the house is wonderful. ... "
" ... An essential in my house! ... "
" ... Works great in our small area. ... "
" ... But I have 3 cats and 2 dogs so there's a lot of traffic in and out of my house. ... "
Delivery
7quickly, product, ordered, fast, expected
+86%
-14%
" ... This arrived the day after I ordered it! ... "
" ... Received this today and so far so good. ... "
" ... Exactly what I expected and arrived very quickly. ... "
" ... Competitive price & quick to ship. ... "
Product As Described
6advertised, work, screen, product, expected
+50%
-50%
" ... Did not work as advertised. ... "
" ... Pure junk and NOT as pictured. ... "
Returns
5return, product, one, back
-100%
" ... Returned this product. ... "
" ... I returned it . ... "
" ... I returned it. ... "
" ... This is the second one I have to throw in the TRASH since my return window has closed. ... "
" ... We had to superglue them back together. ... "
Design
5material, looks, idea, cheap
+40%
-60%
" ... Nice idea but poorly made. ... "
" ... Looked ok out of the box. ... "
" ... The material is lightweight and flimsy. ... "
For Kids
4pets, children, bought
+75%
-25%
" ... Kids and dogs can go in and out, we may have to help the magnets sometime but it works well. ... "
" ... Great for pets and kids. ... "
" ... I bought it for my mother and she loves it. ... "
Original Product
4year
+50%
-50%
" ... I but this year after year and this is definitely a fake. ... "
" ... A pice of junk can not compare with the original. ... "
Overall performance
3well
+100%
" ... Works very well ... "
Cooling
3also
+100%
" ... He thinks it will work well when the weather cools. ... "
" ... Its also great for airflow in the summer. ... "
Network
3works, traffic, live, flies
+100%
" ... Where I live it doesn't really get hot enough for AC most days, but having the afternoon breeze clear the air in the house is wonderful. ... "
" ... Stronger than I expected. ... "
" ... But I have 3 cats and 2 dogs so there's a lot of traffic in and out of my house. ... "
Review Spam Test WARN
In order to keep our review summaries as accurate as possible, we aggressively detect fake reviews. We use various signals to detect unnatural patterns and will gradually expose them here.
PASS
Unverified Review Streak
PASS
High Velocity Reviewers
PASS
Inactive Reviewers
PASS
Reviewer History Overlap
Specifications
Body
Size: 83 meters