Last Updated: February 19, 2020 (Refresh Now)
Honeywell Ceiling Fans 50614 01 Carnegie LED Ceiling Fan 52 Indoor Rustic Barnwood Blades Industrial Cage Light Matte Black
Last Updated: February 19, 2020 (Refresh Now)
7.5
SCORE
/10
Total Reviews
173
Old Reviews
0
Unverified
3
Spam Test
PASS
LED
TYPE
Review Analysis - 170 recent, verified reviews
Detailed Mode
Design
47look, fan, beautiful, works great, rustic
+96%
-4%
" ... We love the look of this ceiling fan. ... "
" ... But looks nice ... "
" ... I love the industrial look. ... "
" ... Love the industrial wood look! ... "
" ... Bought this fan primarily for looks. ... "
" ... Love the way the light looks when turned on. ... "
" ... Love it and it looks exactly like I had hoped. ... "
" ... Looks very nice and well built. ... "
Setup
41fan, installation, easy to install, installed, fans
+66%
-34%
" ... I love that an electrician friend installed it for me! ... "
" ... Came as expected and was very easy to install. ... "
" ... The installation took awhile. ... "
" ... Install was as easy as any other fan. ... "
" ... I kept them safely packaged and had an electrician install. ... "
" ... I’ve installed enough fans in my days that this one was just as easy to install without looking at the instructions. ... "
" ... Very easy installation, I had the old fan down and this one out of the box and up in about 30 minutes. ... "
" ... Love this ceiling fan however, it was a pain for my husband to install! ... "
Remote
41fan, control, receiver, ceiling, noise
+61%
-39%
" ... Our favorite feature is the remote control. ... "
" ... Remote took a little "getting used to" but now that I have, it's great. ... "
" ... The fan is great with the remote control and looks really pretty as well if you’re going for a rustic look! ... "
" ... I read other reviews that had complained about the remote receiver not fitting in the housing very well/easily. ... I have installed ceiling fans with remotes before, so i have experience with the receivers. ... "
" ... The lights and fan speed operate from a remote control on my desk, and once I get the settings just right, it's completely invisible. ... "
" ... Otherwise, the fan looks good, remote works fine and the noise level is low. ... "
" ... Remote works good and it is very aesthetically pleasing. ... "
" ... Thank you to the other reviewers who advised on where to put the remote receiver, very big help!! ... "
Ease of Use
21install, easy to install, fan, looks, difficult to install
+71%
-29%
" ... Not noisy at all, looks great and easy to install. ... "
" ... Pretty easy to install if you have even a little bit of skill. ... "
" ... He actually got through this fairly easy!! ... "
" ... It had me stumped as it did a lot of others I read about, but once you figure it out it's easy. ... "
" ... The fan was difficult to put together but once it was up, it’s beautiful and works great. ... "
" ... It was farely easy to install. ... "
" ... It is very quiet and install was easy. ... "
" ... The fan looks good, was easy to install, and is quiet. ... "
Capacity
17bedroom, house, living room, fan, ceiling
+94%
-6%
" ... Mounted this in the living room. ... "
" ... Using in master bedroom. ... "
" ... Purchased for our large, high ceiling family room. ... "
" ... Got this for my home office in an obscure part of our house, and it is just sublime. ... The office is on a 3rd floor viewable from the street and even neighbors have remarked on how nice it looks. ... "
" ... They not only look great in my bedroom and livingroom, but the family loves them. ... "
" ... But it’s perfect for our room! ... "
" ... Changes the entire room ... "
" ... We bought one for every room in our house. ... "
Sound Quality
15fan, noise, motor, looks, speed
+80%
-20%
" ... The fan is silent quite. ... "
" ... It's very quiet. ... "
" ... I love the look and is very quiet. ... "
" ... A touch on the noisy side with a small humming when it’s on high speed but other then that I’m very pleased. ... "
" ... Good quality, better than old fan, quiet and powerfull. ... "
" ... I love it, their is no noise and it is very eye catching. ... "
" ... Works perfectly no issues, no noise, balanced great on my angle ceiling. ... "
" ... It’s super quiet and looks great. ... "
Features
13bulbs, fan, turn, plenty, lights
+69%
-31%
" ... it takes almost 1 full second for the light to turn on when you hit the light switch. ... "
" ... The light is soft but changing bulbs could make it brighter. ... "
" ... Fan and light are great! ... "
" ... Love the look of this, the light bulbs are a great touch! ... "
" ... The lights are great, love the dimming feature. ... "
" ... The fan is very nice looking and the antique bulbs are a great touch! ... "
" ... the light is bright and the fixture is trendy. ... "
" ... I like this fan/light. ... "
Price
10worth, pay, fan, beautiful, purchase
+80%
-20%
" ... Either way pay attention. ... "
" ... Great fan for a great price. ... "
" ... Love the fan and great price! ... "
" ... I feel for the price it’s a terrific deal! ... "
Fit
10screw, remove, flush mount, screwdriver, mount
+10%
-90%
" ... The directions don't mention there won't be a green if you flush mount it, so the directions could have been better. ... "
" ... Mounted mine as a close-mount, But the blade are not providing really any noticeable breeze . ... compared to the other close-mount/or even flush-mount fans I have seen, that is disappointing and makes the fan pointless. ... "
" ... It wouldn't accept the screw. ... "
" ... They tightened the screws that you are supposed to use to attach the blades so much that it was impossible to unscrew them to actually attach the blades. ... To make it even worse, they are of such poor steel alloy that the threads don't withstand the screwdriver and soon fall apart. ... "
" ... Screws provided did not screw into machined holes. ... "
" ... Do not force, simply turn until the puzzle piece fits. ... We also had difficulty with the machining of the screw holes. ... This lack of information held back our project back as we had to try and locate a compatible sloped ceiling canopy from another manufacturer, as there’s not one available from these folks . ... "
" ... I don't like having the slot to attach the blades and the blade screws were so tight I even ended up stripping one of the screw heads, but it wouldn't stop me from buying another one. ... "
" ... The screws are phillips head and I could only remove 8 of 10. ... I had to remove fixture and turn upside down to get an angle to try and loosen. ... There is no reason these screws (which you have to use and remove) should not be hand tight. ... "
Software Platform
8description, connect to alexa, advertised, work, integration
+13%
-88%
" ... Amazon advertised it could be voice controlled using Alexa. ... "
" ... This fan doesn't connect to Alexa. ... "
" ... Does NOT work with Echo/Alexa as advertised. ... 2 stars because of the false advertising regarding Alexa compatibility. ... "
" ... Just a needless dangerous fire hazard to be put in. ... "
" ... The description say it works with Alexa but there are no instructions on how to do so . ... "
Marketplace
7pictures, picture, looks, even, goes
+43%
-57%
" ... Amazon needs to address this as this was the main reason for the purchase. ... "
" ... I called Amazon and it's on its way back . ... "
" ... They specically said Amazon misinformed me ... "
Device Compatibility
7connect to alexa, work, voice, instructions, fan
+29%
-71%
" ... This fan doesn't connect to Alexa. ... "
" ... Does NOT work with Echo/Alexa as advertised. ... 2 stars because of the false advertising regarding Alexa compatibility. ... "
" ... The description say it works with Alexa but there are no instructions on how to do so . ... "
Build Quality
7screws, screwdriver, screw, rod, apart
+29%
-71%
" ... There is not 1 single piece of this fan that is rubbed bronze. ... "
" ... To make it even worse, they are of such poor steel alloy that the threads don't withstand the screwdriver and soon fall apart. ... "
" ... The screws are screwed in so tight they are impossible to remove. ... "
" ... Screws provided did not screw into machined holes. ... He took it apart to find the switch had broken inside the unit causing the live wires to be exposed. ... "
Cables
5wires, live, apart
+60%
-40%
" ... So the wiring was all in tact, just a simple swap. ... "
" ... I was advised by my electrician it was easy to install and wire. ... "
" ... It lays flat, flush to the ceiling and it must go in before you hang the motor and connect the wires. ... "
Returns
5call
-100%
" ... not worth the hassle of return. ... "
" ... I ended up returning it and just going to lowes. ... "
" ... Wish I would’ve unboxed it sooner and now I am unable to return. ... "
" ... Too hard to pack up to return, but will be in the trash, after i can find another 3 hours to take down and replace. ... "
" ... Had to call to get a replacement still waiting. ... "
Product Reliability
4day
-100%
" ... after 6 hours I finally called it quits. ... "
" ... I'm a contractor and this is junk. ... "
" ... The following day after that it miraculously worked again, and the day after that - stopped again. ... "
" ... One bulb was broken. ... "
Device Stand
4one, mounting, inches, flush, way
+50%
-50%
" ... compared to the other close-mount/or even flush-mount fans I have seen, that is disappointing and makes the fan pointless. ... "
" ... The directions don't mention there won't be a green if you flush mount it, so the directions could have been better. ... "
Product As Described
3picture, looks, even, goes
+100%
" ... Looks better than the picture. ... "
" ... Does work as advertised. ... "
" ... It looks like the photo and arrived undamaged and on time. ... "
Storage
3love, look, ceiling, got
+67%
-33%
" ... Once we got past fitting all the components inside a very small space, lots of cursing later we got to the next step and the screw hole was machined poorly. ... "
Review Spam Test PASS
In order to keep our review summaries as accurate as possible, we aggressively detect fake reviews. We use various signals to detect unnatural patterns and will gradually expose them here.
Specifications
Display
Type: LED