Last Updated: September 12, 2019 (Refresh Now)
BENCMATE Protective Inflatable Collar for Dogs and Cats Soft Pet Recovery Collar Does Not Block Vision E Collar
Last Updated: September 12, 2019 (Refresh Now)
7.1
SCORE
/10
Total Reviews
1000
Old Reviews
0
Unverified
20
Spam Test
PASS
Review Analysis - 980 recent, verified reviews
Detailed Mode
Comfort
265cone, surgery, pillow, much more comfortable, stitches
+78%
-22%
" ... Otherwise, seems like a good product for protecting the ear from being scratched. ... "
" ... My lab had chest surgery. ... My pet is more comfortable with it fully inflated. ... "
" ... My Lil Yorkie after Surgery. ... So much more Comfortable for your Pet then those Cones ... "
" ... We are only on day two of this product but so far so good, and way more comfortable for her than a plastic cone. ... "
" ... I don't know of any dog lover that wants their dog to wear one. ... I feel this collar minimizes these concerns as much as reasonably possible. ... Very happy with it and it makes me feel a whole let less guilty as it is more comfortable than those Elizabethan collars ... "
" ... My dog is so much more comfortable. ... "
" ... She was able to maneuver better and was much more comfortable for her. ... "
" ... Our blind dog freaked out over wearing our preferred Four Paws Comfy Cone but was very tolerant of wearing this. ... "
Build Quality
185plastic cone, cone, zipper broke, zipper, inflatable
+43%
-57%
" ... Zipper broke on one immediately. ... Using the loops to attach the inflatable collar to the dogs' normal collar kept the dogs from getting the inflatable collar off, but they could both just bend and reach the incision (from being neutered). ... "
" ... Zipper broke the first day of it being worn. ... It’s not wide enough to prevent rubbing or scratching. ... "
" ... He had dew claws removed on both rear legs, and he was neutered at the same time. ... "
" ... Stick with the regular plastic E-collar, don't waste your money on this. ... "
" ... We can still use it, that's why I'm giving it a 2 star review but the zipper on the outer cover broke after washing it once. ... "
" ... I got this product in hope it would be more comfortable than the plastic E-collar. ... "
" ... Dog got it off his neck and chewed it to pieces in the first night. ... "
" ... And he didn't fight it, as he did in the plastic cone ... "
Fit
110dog, zipper broke, cone, zipper, loops
+56%
-44%
" ... It's a blow up cone instead so its air filled and soft like a pillow case on the outside. ... "
" ... The price and fit is awesome! ... "
" ... It was a perfect fit for my dog ... "
" ... The XL fit her perfectly and lets her roam around the house without bumping into things that the usual cone would. ... "
" ... It held the air with no leakage. ... "
" ... Just measure snug or it may be too big. ... "
" ... The size was accurate and the velcro allows for a perfect and solid fit. ... "
" ... He hasn’t scratched at it or tried to remove it yet, so we’ll see how well it holds up over time. ... "
Ease of Use
46easy to inflate, easy, take, inflate, easy to put
+85%
-15%
" ... Easy to put on and take off. ... "
" ... The cone is easy to blow up and pretty durable as well. ... "
" ... Easy to inflate. ... "
" ... Easy to take on and off, does it’s job keepin my little guy from licking at his surgical wound. ... "
" ... So easy to inflate and my little love seems to not have issues with it. ... "
" ... Plain and simple. ... "
" ... Easy to Putin and take off and easy to inflate. ... "
" ... Easy to clean once he was healed up. ... "
Product Reliability
45worked great, lasted, two weeks, popped, cone
+33%
-67%
" ... I bought the small originally, and that worked for less than a week. ... "
" ... It was effective for about 3 weeks before deflating, so now it is completely useless. ... "
" ... didn't even last ONE day ... "
" ... stopped any licking of stitches. ... "
" ... Does not work! ... "
" ... This only lasted 2 days for us unfortunately. ... "
" ... Update: July 8th 8 days later ... "
" ... It's been less than two weeks. ... "
Price
45price, worth, money, waste your money, well worth
+40%
-60%
" ... Stick with the regular plastic E-collar, don't waste your money on this. ... "
" ... Waste of money. ... "
" ... Waste of money. ... "
" ... Don't waste your money. ... "
" ... It was useless and completely waste of money. ... "
" ... Waste of money. ... "
" ... Yeah don't waste your money. ... "
" ... I would give this zero stars if I could and barely worth my time to return so just a big waste of money. ... "
Sleep Tracking
43able to sleep, pillow, dog, comfortably, cone
+91%
-9%
" ... Our Dog loved this so much more than the cone, he was able to sleep comfortable with out touching his stitches ... "
" ... My dog had no problem sleeping while wearing it . ... "
" ... Sleeping very well now, using it daily & nightly, until the I hot spots/infection goes away!! ... "
" ... At night, this inflatable collar allowed us to sleep without concern as the leak rate was slow enough to last 5-6 hrs. ... "
" ... He wasn't scared or nervous when we put it on him and the best part is that he was able to sleep. ... "
" ... This let's him run and sleep comfortably, while taking my worries away of him scratching his stitches. ... "
" ... He is much happier and is able to sleep and move around more freely and more comfortably. ... "
" ... Also so much easier to rest and sleep much better ! ... "
Size
41small, travel pillow, next size, medium, correct size
+78%
-22%
" ... I purchased the large and it fits perfect. ... "
" ... I picked the size best suited for my labrador. ... "
" ... When he has it on, he uses it as a portable pillow. ... "
" ... The large is a great size. ... "
" ... I ordered the size per the size chart but he was still easily able to reach it. ... "
" ... He literally used it like a travel pillow. ... "
" ... Bigger than needed. ... "
" ... Size small fit well on this 7 pounder. ... "
Returns
25returning, returned, item, replacement, find
-100%
" ... I bought two but apparently I can't return it. ... "
" ... Looking for a refund . ... "
" ... I did that but it was way too big & must return. ... "
" ... Immediately returning this item unfortunately . ... "
" ... Because of this I will be returning it and buying a traditional cone. ... "
" ... Overall, I'm thinking about returning the other one, I bought two ... Since I bought two, I'll call the company first and see if it makes sense to return the unused one and find out if they have a better solution for the somewhat repaired one my dog is currently wearing. ... "
" ... Will be returning, as it didn’t replace the cone from the vet. ... "
" ... Tried to return for a refund (to buy something else) and they’re sending me another one. ... "
Marketplace
17seller, thanks, thank, pictures, fast
+88%
-12%
" ... On Amazon, the same one the Vet told me about ,was $35. ... "
" ... The pictures say more than I can. ... "
" ... Thank You for this product ! ... "
" ... Exactly like the picture! ... "
" ... Hank says thanks! ... "
" ... Thanks to prime I got it the next day. ... "
" ... Great, as described. ... "
" ... So much better than the original cones. ... "
Storage
17large, medium size, dog, spaces, pitbull
+94%
-6%
" ... My dog can maneuver more easy through tight spaces and reach food bowl easily. ... "
" ... We ordered the same in the next size down and fits perfect. ... "
" ... I like that it’s washable, and you can deflate for storage. ... "
" ... We ordered the small and medium size because we weren’t sure which size. ... "
" ... Fit my 35lb French bulldog nicely when I blew it up fully. ... "
" ... Do yourself and the animal a favor and buy one to place in the drawer until needed . ... "
" ... We have a French bulldog and their necks are roughly the same size as their heads. ... "
" ... Buying the XL is a perfect fit, and there is plenty of room if you have a larger dog. ... "
For Travel
15flight, trip, pillow, vet, trips
+87%
-13%
" ... She used it like we would use a travel pillow. ... "
" ... And seems to love the idea that she a 'travel' pillow!! ... "
" ... It is made of soft fabric that can be detached and tossed in the wash and can be easily deflated for travel or portability. ... "
" ... I used on my 4 lb chihuahua and she used it almost like a travel pillow. ... "
" ... Our dog had to fly home from Florida to California and the collar was perfect for the flight. ... "
" ... I might even use it to sit on my next plane flight ... "
" ... Heck, I may even take this pillow on my next flight for myself! ... "
" ... Tried it on myself and may take it on a plane next vacay. ... "
For Running
10run, everything, cone, comfortable, vet
+80%
-20%
" ... It worked beautifully and allowed my pal to heal with minimal discomfort while still being able to play and run. ... "
" ... He was comfortable sleeping with it, and he was still able to run and play with it on. ... "
" ... However, since the vet recommends keeping her on a leash when taking her outside to prevent her from running around, she seems to not want to go to the bathroom with it on. ... "
" ... He's running and playing and no issues going thru tight spaces like around furniture and thru doorways. ... "
" ... It works, he loves running around, and tho weird it works. ... "
" ... He was at least comfortable, not running into things, and slept well. ... "
" ... Good to use a secondary collar for walks while wearing ... "
" ... This was amazing until I came home to my dog running collar-free today. ... "
Band
10collar, straps, wearing, velcro strap, zipper
+20%
-80%
" ... Over the week that she wore it, she only popped it off once which was related to the collar inside. ... "
" ... Had this product for 24 hours and my pit rescue broke the straps that connect it to his collar in one day. ... "
" ... My Golden could reach her spay incision while wearing this and she managed to chew off the strap ... "
" ... First, 2 of the loop’s stitching came loose . ... "
" ... the 2nd night the velcro strap broke. ... This morning, (Monday, day 3) after careful investigation, I found I could sew the strap onto itself ... hopefully the strap won't rip in another place. ... Other than the broken zipper and strap happening on the first day - He's comfortable in it ... Broken zipper and repaired strap. ... "
" ... Unfortunately the 2nd night my dog wore it the strap somehow wore through. ... "
" ... The straps that hold the collar on ripped off within one hour of him having it on. ... "
Delivery
10fast, well, quickly, box, received
+100%
" ... It shipped fast. ... "
" ... Fast Shipping, Nice product. ... "
" ... It arrived on time and we tried it on him. ... "
" ... I purchased this, it arrived quickly and worked VERY well. ... "
" ... Deliver was fast and the product itself is well made. ... "
" ... We purchased this same day and it arrived within hours. ... "
" ... It arrived quickly. ... "
Cleaning
10reach, mess, easy to clean, cone, wound
+50%
-50%
" ... what a mess! ... "
" ... But, we heard it pop and got to her quickly to clean up the mess. ... "
For Kids
8toy, surgery, pup, old school, lab
+88%
-13%
" ... My pup thought I got him a brand new chew toy. ... "
" ... In this instance, the old school collar is the best. ... "
" ... My kids said she looked like she was wearing a floaty. ... "
" ... Our pup can finally chew his toys post op. ... "
" ... Much better than the old school cones. ... "
" ... My fur kid doesn't like this however it helps 100% w her not being able to lick her boo boo. ... "
" ... Bought this for our 2 year old lab. ... "
Capacity
8house, cone, still, traditional, room
+88%
-13%
" ... Cat cannot reach his wound, but can still navigate the house. ... "
" ... Overall, I’d recommend for small dogs who are getting spayed! ... "
" ... Rocky was banging up the walls and woodwork around the house with the traditional ecollar. ... "
" ... I’m so glad to have this option because it’s easier on the whole family. ... "
" ... She can maneuver around the house perfectly. ... "
" ... I walked in and she was panting and her floatie was across the room!! ... "
" ... I like that it does not damage furniture and walls. ... "
Hair
8dog, hair, cut, collar, licking
+38%
-63%
" ... He has had hot spots over a week, and had to have the area around his ear shaved. ... "
" ... We have a collar that breaks when necessary but it is still getting caught around his neck. ... "
" ... The collars might work if you have a small dog that can't fit his nose over the collar, but I wouldn't chance it /waste the time with this product. ... "
" ... The cone is so uncomfortable for them, but the inflatable can be pushed off over their ears and nose using their paws. ... "
" ... My dogs neck is 12”, which is the cut off for Med/ large. ... "
Battery Life
8last, even, lasted, 24
+13%
-88%
" ... Didn't even get to use it for 48 hours. ... "
" ... Lasted less than 12 hours. ... "
" ... Only Lasted for a couple hours though. ... "
" ... The product did not last - a whole formed in under 4 hours, thus not allowing it to stay inflated. ... "
" ... So It deflated every few hours!! ... "
" ... It was a shame that it didn't even last 24 hours. ... "
" ... This didn't even last 24 hours. ... "
Overall performance
7done, pretty, fast
+86%
-14%
" ... It shipped fast. ... "
" ... Otherwise it does the job . ... "
" ... Got the job done. ... "
" ... Does the job well! ... "
" ... It does its job and we can still hug and cuddle our pup. ... "
" ... All in all, it's pretty secure and gets the job done! ... "
Washing
6washed, easy, cover, fabric, dirt
+67%
-33%
" ... It's also very easy to wash and inflate. ... "
" ... I haven’t cleaned it yet but I’m sure it will wash beautifully. ... "
" ... It washed nicely. ... "
" ... It comes with a removable cover so easy to wash. ... "
Sound Quality
5dog, size, medium, cone
+80%
-20%
" ... She is currently sound asleep with it on. ... "
" ... The only reason i gave a 4 star review is because my dog makes a snoring noise half the day unless he’s standing. ... "
" ... I swear my dog made a sigh of relief noise when I put it on him :) ... "
" ... Sounds like they need an “extra medium” size. ... "
Defective Delivery
5returned, received, quickly, item, box
+20%
-80%
" ... It was damaged. ... "
" ... Do not waste your money on this defective product! ... "
" ... Bought a faulty product. ... "
Product As Described
4described
+100%
" ... The pictures say more than I can. ... "
" ... Exactly like the picture! ... "
" ... Works as well as described. ... "
" ... Great, as described. ... "
Food Items
4+75%
-25%
" ... Now he’s back to only crying when it’s time for dinner! ... "
" ... I’ve used soft collars of all shapes and sizes but this takes the cake. ... "
" ... We put some leftover stew on top of his food and he got up immediately and ate the entire bowl of food ... "
Water Resistance
4like, water, took, pool, eat
+25%
-75%
" ... My Frenchie Boston mix managed to get it off while in his kennel in the 20 minutes it took me to shower! ... The velcro however was still attached in the original position I put it in before my shower. ... "
" ... It is inflatable like a pool inflatable, so he was only able to manage wiggling out after a couple days when it deflated a bit. ... "
" ... It’s like a pool float where if there’s a hole in it, it’s nearly impossible to find. ... "
Setup
3stitches
+100%
" ... Easy to assemble. ... "
" ... It was easy to install around his neck and kept him from reaching his tail and butt where he has 100 stitches after the operation. ... "
" ... After I read the instructions this should work just fine. ... "
Color
3+100%
" ... This inflatable color is the best. ... "
" ... It’s a fun color ... "
" ... Although the color was nicely made, it was too small for my little guy. ... "
Water Usage
3eat, able, water, chew
+100%
" ... The best part for me is that he can drink water as needed, which he could not do with a traditional cone. ... "
" ... He was able to eat, drink water and chew on his toys with this. ... "
" ... They were able to eat and drink water with this on. ... "
Drying
3washed, properly, prevent, heal, clean
+33%
-67%
" ... I have to clean, dry, and change his bandage twice a day. ... So I figured I'd try this inflatable collar to prevent him from licking it, and allowing it to dry out and heal properly. ... That's what I needed it to PREVENT, so his wound could dry out and heal properly! ... "
Ease of Cleaning
3clean, mess, easy to use
+67%
-33%
Network
3like, cone, traditional, house, furniture
+100%
" ... No corners to catch on walls like with the cone. ... "
" ... Rocky was banging up the walls and woodwork around the house with the traditional ecollar. ... "
" ... I like that it does not damage furniture and walls. ... "
Review Spam Test PASS
In order to keep our review summaries as accurate as possible, we aggressively detect fake reviews. We use various signals to detect unnatural patterns and will gradually expose them here.
PASS
Unverified Review Streak
PASS
High Velocity Reviewers
PASS
Inactive Reviewers
PASS
Reviewer History Overlap
Specifications
No specs available.